CoA orders PhilHealth to return P247.9-M allowances




MANILA — The Commission on Audit has ordered the Philippine Health Insurance Corp. to return P247.88 million in unauthorized benefits given to its employees.

In two separate decisions, the CoA affirmed the 13 notices of disallowance issued from January 2009 to April 2010 on various employee bonuses and allowances.

The CoA did not even discuss 11 of these NDs covering P229.36 million. It rejected outright the petitions of former president and chief executive officer Eduardo Banzon because they were elevated to the commission proper beyond the allowable 180-day period.

“Having attained finality, the decision is immutable and unalterable, and may no longer be modified in any respect,” the CoA said.

Meanwhile, it affirmed the disallowance of P16.28 million paid to employees as an “efficiency gift” for the year 2007, on the ground of lack of approval from the Office of the President.

The CoA rejected Philhealth’s argument that it was exempted from the Salary Standardization Law and had autonomy to grant the benefits by virtue of the National Health Insurance Act of 1995.

According to the COA decision, the authority of the Philhealth board of directors to fix their own compensation and position classification system is “not absolute,” because it is “still duty bound to observe guidelines and policies” and report its compensation plans to the President to ensure compliance with the law.

The CoA said Philhealth could not claim to be in good faith, because Section 6 of Presidential Decree No. 1597 required it to secure first the approval of the Office of the President and the Department of Budget and Management. It also noted that “the officials are not in good faith due to previous NDs” on similar allowances.

Although Philhealth employees might be in good faith, the CoA added that the “one who receives something by mistake has the obligation to return it” under Articles 2154 and 2160 of the Civil Code of the Philippines.

As for the P2.24 million paid as “shuttle service assistance” for the year 2009, the CoA affirmed that it was an “additional allowance” prohibited under Item b, Section 3 of Administrative Order No. 103, which suspended increased benefits to the employees of government corporations.

Although the order allowed the grant of additional benefits under a valid collective negotiation agreement, the CoA noted that Philhealth’s CNA actually established the shuttle service itself—but not its conversion into an allowance.

“There is a clear distinction between the shuttle service and the SSA,” the decision read. “The former partakes of a service vehicle for the comfort and convenience of its officers and employees in commuting to and from the office chargeable against the Maintenance and Other Operating Expenses (MOOE) while the latter is a form of monetary benefit charged against Personal Services.”  SFM

Recent Stories:

Complete stories on our Digital Edition newsstand for tablets, netbooks and mobile phones; 14-issue free trial. About to step out? Get breaking alerts on your mobile.phone. Text ON INQ BREAKING to 4467, for Globe, Smart and Sun subscribers in the Philippines.

Disclaimer: The comments uploaded on this site do not necessarily represent or reflect the views of management and owner of INQUIRER.net. We reserve the right to exclude comments that we deem to be inconsistent with our editorial standards.

Copyright © 2017,

To subscribe to the Philippine Daily Inquirer newspaper in the Philippines, call +63 2 896-6000 for Metro Manila and Metro Cebu or email your subscription request here.

Factual errors? Contact the Philippine Daily Inquirer's day desk. Believe this article violates journalistic ethics? Contact the Inquirer's Reader's Advocate. Or write The Readers' Advocate: c/o Philippine Daily Inquirer Chino Roces Avenue corner Yague and Mascardo Streets, Makati City, Metro Manila, Philippines Or fax nos. +63 2 8974793 to 94


  • CoA orders PhilHealth to return P247.9-M allowances
  • Swedes scratch heads at Trump’s suggestion of major incident
  • Panelo:  Drug raps vs De Lima based on documents and testimonies
  • House majority to hold caucus on death penalty bill
  • AFP still open to peace with Reds
  • Sports

  • ABL: Alab Pilipinas blow chance, bow to Dragons
  • Meneses feels sorry for Adamson’s struggles, hopes for turnaround
  • Molde breaks out of scoring slump to help UP win over UST
  • Gorayeb blasts NU in three-set loss to La Salle
  • Reyes takes blame for UST’s 3rd loss in 4 games
  • Lifestyle

  • Fireworks set to music draws Saturday crowds at Manila Bay
  • Your Super guide to the Penshoppe Capital
  • Do we need a women’s march?
  • A Pirate’s life for Mclaude Guadaña
  • Let’s talk about sex: Juan Ekis’ ‘20 Questions’ brings audience to seat of action
  • Entertainment

  • James Earl Jones, Donald Glover cast in ‘Lion King’ remake
  • ‘AlDub’ makes the leap from ‘Kalyeserye’ to ‘teleserye’
  • How Shailene Woodley transformed into an activist
  • Ping Medina, Sandino Martin name their idols, inspirations
  • Katy Perry bashed for ‘making fun’ of Britney
  • Business

  • BSP chief Tetangco gets FinanceAsia achievement award
  • PH economic freedom ranking jumps from 70th to 58th
  • Pulling an ailing industry back on its feet
  • Foodpanda delivers the goods
  • Aboitiz ramps up spending for ‘CSR 2.0’
  • Technology

  • WATCH: Nintendo Switch trailer shows how fun multiplayer can be
  • ‘League of Legends’ adds practice mode
  • Loon internet by Alphabet gets closer to deployment
  • Gandalf the Grey wanders through New Zealand with amateur photographer
  • Crash Bandicoot N. Sane Trilogy for PS4 goes on sale
  • Opinion

  • The ultimate streaming showdown: Netflix vs iFlix vs HOOQ
  • Editorial cartoon, February 19, 2017
  • Cottage industry
  • Using criminals as witnesses
  • Who is brave?
  • Global Nation

  • Russian security experts to train select AFP, PNP personnel
  • Russia offers to share intel data with PH
  • Duterte to visit Middle East this month
  • 10 resign in protest from White House AAPI advisory body
  • Korean’s widow wants NBI out of slay probe

    • IN PHOTOS: New Year all over the world

      Read More

    • Can the human race still do anything to stop climate change?

      Read More

    • What will be the Philippines’ place in the new world order?

      Read More

    • Will Philippine history be made or unmade as we know it?

      Read More

    • What blocks the Filipino woman’s path to gender equality?

      Read More

    • What should President Duterte focus on, after drugs?

      Read More

    • What will it really take to ease traffic in the Philippines?

      Read More

    • The “Two Trumps” surface in president-elect’s transition

      Read More

    • ‘Black Friday’ marchers denounce burial of Marcos at Libingan

      Read More

    • LOOK: Ferdinand Marcos laid to rest at Libingan

      Read More

    • 1,200 jobless as garments firm closes

      Read More

    • Sale of pigs left in Pampanga ‘shabu’ lab nets P7M

      Read More

    • Governor serves suspension but insists no basis for graft raps

      Read More

    • ‘Helen’ enters PH; moderate to heavy rains expected

      Read More

    • PPP deal eyes new SLEX exit to Cabuyao

      Read More