Quantcast

Comelec can still disqualify bogus partylist groups, says lawmaker

By

Bayan Muna Rep. Neri Colmenares INQUIRER.net FILE PHOTO

MANILA, Philippines–There are still ways for the Commission on Elections to purge sham partylist groups from the ballot, despite the recent Supreme Court ruling that political parties and groups not representing the marginalized and underrepresented can join the partylist voting, according to Bayan Muna Representative Neri Colmenares.

Colmenares said the Comelec could still take a closer look at the partylist groups and deny them from participating in the polls if they are shown to not be working for the particular sector they claim to represent.

They could also be ousted from the race for violating election laws, he added.

He noted that the Supreme Court had tasked the Comelec to determine which of the disqualified groups can join the elections based on the tribunal’s new standards.

“Since the grounds for disqualifying these groups include other grounds such as failure to prove their advocacy for a sector, or violation of election laws, then these rich powerful partylist groups can still … (remain) disqualified for these grounds since the Supreme Court decision did not touch on these issues,” he said in a statement.

Colmenares also assailed the Supreme Court ruling, saying it paves the way for political and economic elites to join the partylist system and edge out marginalized sectors that need representation. It disregarded the social justice principle, he said.

“Under the Constitution, the partylist system was intended as a ‘social justice’ tool to allow the poor to have a voice in Congress by allotting 20 percent of the seats for the marginalized and underrepresented,” he said.

He contended that it was a practice around the world to give preferential treatment to the downtrodden and underrepresented, and this is what the partylist system was intended to do.

“Affirmative action, or preferential treatment for the poor, is a recognized concept throughout the world in recognition of the fact that the poor cannot compete with the rich in the so called ‘level playing field,’” he said.

The Supreme Court ruling was like pitting welterweights with the heavyweights, he added.

“Of course, the poor partylist groups are no match to the economic elites and rich politicians in any election. That’s why the poor are given the partylist system because they cannot win in a district congressional election,” he said.

The Makabayan coalition, in a separate statement, blasted the Supreme Court ruling, saying it was “suspiciously strange” that the tribunal backtracked from earlier rulings that essentially excluded powerful groups from joining the partylist race.

“Makabayan urges the Supreme Court to reconsider its highly unpopular decision and preserve the long established social justice doctrine that the partylist system is only for the marginalized and the underrepresented. We call on the Commission on Elections to defend its decision in disqualifying these fake partylist groups and demand reconsideration from the Supreme Court,” it said.

It said the law was intended to enable the marginalized and underrepresented to join Congress, which is why the system must enhance their chances of getting seats in the legislature.

Thus, allowing lawmakers comprising 80 percent of the House of Representatives to join the race for the 20 percent partylist seats nullifies the intent of the party-list system, it further said.

Recent Stories:

Complete stories on our Digital Edition newsstand for tablets, netbooks and mobile phones; 14-issue free trial. About to step out? Get breaking alerts on your mobile.phone. Text ON INQ BREAKING to 4467, for Globe, Smart and Sun subscribers in the Philippines.

Disclaimer: The comments uploaded on this site do not necessarily represent or reflect the views of management and owner of INQUIRER.net. We reserve the right to exclude comments that we deem to be inconsistent with our editorial standards.

Copyright © 2014,

To subscribe to the Philippine Daily Inquirer newspaper in the Philippines, call +63 2 896-6000 for Metro Manila and Metro Cebu or email your subscription request here.

Factual errors? Contact the Philippine Daily Inquirer's day desk. Believe this article violates journalistic ethics? Contact the Inquirer's Reader's Advocate. Or write The Readers' Advocate: c/o Philippine Daily Inquirer Chino Roces Avenue corner Yague and Mascardo Streets, Makati City, Metro Manila, Philippines Or fax nos. +63 2 8974793 to 94



News

  • Burkina Faso army general takes power
  • A ghost story
  • Burkina Faso leader steps down, vote in 90 days
  • ‘Nuri’ may not make landfall in PH and instead head for Japan—Pagasa
  • Aquino inspects ports, terminals ahead of All Saints’ Day
  • Sports

  • Alaska blacks out Meralco in Halloween eve showdown
  • LeBron falters in emotional return to Cleveland
  • Daniel Padilla, Kiefer Ravena lead star-studded Hoops for Hope charity game
  • Knicks ruin LeBron’s homecoming game
  • Alaska, Meralco duel for solo PH Cup lead
  • Lifestyle

  • New search may locate grave of Spanish poet Lorca
  • Local, foreign celebs dress up, cross dress for Halloween
  • French-British brand with androgynous appeal arrives in Manila
  • So ancient Balinese, yet so contemporary
  • Swatch sets world launch of BenCab limited edition
  • Entertainment

  • Stars in the news
  • ‘Walking Dead’ creator isn’t dark and brooding
  • Tom Hanks gets serious
  • Managing hypertension
  • Kamote, November 1, 2014
  • Business

  • Aquino slashes real property taxes on facilities of power producers contracted by GOCCs
  • LPG prices coming down after midnight Friday
  • DoubleDragon raises P7.4 B through debt paper
  • Taxes may be paid with credit cards, if House bill passes muster
  • Semiconductor company braces for exciting future of industry
  • Technology

  • Focus on social listening
  • Co-creator of Android mobile software leaves Google
  • Smartphone sales lifted by emerging markets
  • Computers help search for the dead
  • 9 common scams on social media
  • Opinion

  • No one cared enough
  • Editorial cartoon, October 31, 2014
  • ‘Wang-wang’ lives
  • Birth of Frankenstein
  • Frightening ourselves
  • Global Nation

  • Sueselbeck deportation a ‘win-win’ situation–military
  • MIAA suspends fare, terminal fee integration order
  • Pasay court stops planned integration of terminal fee into airfare
  • Sueselbeck visits Laude grave on eve of return to Germany
  • Laude fiancé to leave PH on Nov. 1
  • PHOTOS AND VIDEOS

    • Burkina Faso leader steps down, vote in 90 days

      Read More

    • Audio recording of Binay interview‎ on Batangas property bared

      Read More

    • Zambian president dies after long illness

      Read More

    • Obama on Ebola fight: US can’t seal itself off

      Read More

    • 100 buried alive in Sri Lanka tea region mudslide–minister

      Read More

    • Filipino ‘mash-up’ artist shares instant fame

      Read More

    • Makati implements traffic rerouting, road closures starting Oct. 31

      Read More

    • Poll finds some Anglican priests do not believe in God

      Read More

    • NASA commercial supply rocket explodes at liftoff

      Read More

    • Aquino: No more 2nd term

      Read More

    • [VIDEO] Liberian doctor uses HIV drug on Ebola patients

      Read More

    • [VIDEO] Kidnapped Nigerian women tell of Boko Haram abuse

      Read More

    • Hong Kong activists mark one month of ‘Umbrella Movement’

      Read More

    • Hawaii lava forces residents to get ready to flee

      Read More

    • BP spill left big oily ‘bathtub ring’ on seafloor

      Read More