Quantcast

Genuino charged over P258-M coffee overprice

By

Efraim C. Genuino INQUIRER FILE PHOTO

Three former officials of the state-run Philippine Amusement and Gaming Corp. (Pagcor) and its coffee supplier may be having sleepless nights these days.

A year after President Benigno Aquino dropped his bombshell on the agency’s P258-million bill for coffee, Pagcor filed a plunder and graft complaint against its former chairman Efraim Genuino.

Also named in the complaint filed in the Office of the Ombudsman Tuesday were Rafael Francisco and Rene Figueroa, former Pagcor president and senior vice president, respectively, and Carlota Cristi Manalo-Tan, the owner of Promolabels Inc., the  former Pagcor coffee supplier.

Manalo-Tan is the wife of Johnny Tan, a “known ally” of Genuino and the second nominee of the Bida party-list group  identified with the former Pagcor chief.

In the complaint filed by present directors Jose Tanjuatco and Enriquito Nuguid, Pagcor alleged that Genuino and his officials entered into concession agreements with Promolabels from 2001 to 2010, and in the process, enriched themselves by purchasing overpriced Figaro coffee products.

The beverage was provided free to customers of state-run casinos.

Pagcor said that from 2005 to 2008, five Casino Filipino branches paid Promolabels P258 million for coffee products.

74-percent overprice

The products were overpriced by 9 percent to 74 percent, contrary to the agreement that the prices of Promolabels’ products would be similar to mall prices.

“For the year 2005 to 2008 alone, Pagcor could have saved at least P78 million if only the prices of Promolabels’ Figaro coffee products were the same as those of other Figaro franchisees,” Pagcor said in its complaint.

Pagcor said Genuino, Francisco and Figueroa had been repeatedly informed about the losses that Casino Filipino branches were incurring because of the Promolabels transactions, but they did not do anything about it.

“They refused or otherwise failed to act to stem or prevent further losses,” the complaint said.

Persecution

Speaking through his lawyer Ramon Esguerra, Genuino belied the claim of the current Pagcor management that casino players had been given free coffee.

“This is another case of persecution in so far as the allies of former President (Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo) are concerned,” Esguerra quoted the former Pagcor chairman as saying.

Esguerra surmised that the case was filed in time for President Benigno Aquino’s State of the Nation Address (Sona) on July 23.

“Remember that they tried to build this case as early as last year and yet, they are filing it only now,” the lawyer said. “They are just reviving this issue.”

Total of P1 billion

Mr.  Aquino disclosed in his Sona last year that Pagcor had spent P1 billion for coffee during the Arroyo administration. He joked that former officials of the gaming firm might not have been able to sleep because of the copious amounts of the stimulant they must have drunk.

Pagcor legal chief Jay Santiago told reporters that the Promolabels contracts were part of the P1 billion spent for coffee by the previous Pagcor administration, and that the latter had hired other concessionaires in the past years.

But the current Pagcor administration decided to file the complaint over the Promolabels contract first to make an example of it, Santiago said.

He said that if Pagcor had waited until the review and documentation of the entire P1-billion coffee expenses were completed, it would be unable to file the complaint until several years from now.

But he added that the review of the other coffee deals was still ongoing, and Pagcor would file cases in the future, if necessary.

Santiago said the complaint for the coffee deals was filed only yesterday, a year after the President disclosed the expenses, because the agency’s auditors had to pore over a decade’s worth of documents.

“What’s important is that we have filed it and we have completed the filing,” he said.

Coincidence

Santiago added that it was just a coincidence that the complaint was filed a few days before Mr. Aquino’s next Sona.

Pagcor said the board led by Genuino approved the proposal of Figaro Coffee Co. to set up kiosks in Casino Filipino branches on May 16, 2001. The prices of its beverages should be the same as those of similar beverages sold in malls.

Pagcor then gave Promolabels, a Figaro franchisee, concession agreements in seven Casino Filipino branches. Carlota Tan signed the concession agreements for Promolabels.

No bidding, SEC registration

Pagcor said Promolabels’ seven contracts had given it a virtual monopoly of the coffee served in Casino Filipino branches.

But it found that the contracts were awarded without the required public bidding. Promolabels’ three-and five-year contracts were extended and renewed without any public bidding as well, it added.

Pagcor also learned that Promolabels was not registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission, contrary to what was stated in its Pagcor contract.

COA findings

Pagcor said that as early as 2006, the Commission on Audit (COA) had raised concerns about the validity and implementation of the concession agreements with Promolabels and pointed out that a public bidding should have been conducted as required by the procurement law.

The audit reports also found disparities between the prices of Promolabels’ Figaro products and those of other Figaro franchisees, including an overprice of up to 74 percent.

The audit reports said that Pagcor could have saved a lot of money had Promolabels prices been similar to those of other Figaro shops outside Casino Filipino.

Despite these reports, Pagcor said its former officials did not demand that Promolabels lower its prices. They even went out of their way to justify Promolabels’ higher prices, it added.

The explanations were issued just a few days after the audit reports, indicating that the former officials did not even bother to conduct a thorough review of Promolabel’s reasons, it further said.

Yearly increases

Pagcor said Figueroa even allowed Promolabels to increase its prices a year later.

By doing all this, the former Pagcor officials “caused undue injury to the government and gave Manalo-Tan unwarranted benefits, advantages and preferences,” Pagcor said.

In a statement, Carlota Tan welcomed the filing of the case against her, saying “this will provide us the chance and opportunities to present all the facts and necessary evidence that the court will require from us.”

“Although this will be the first time that a mere concessionaire is being charged with plunder, we firmly believe that in the end, the current judicial system will allow us to prove our innocence,” she said.

Pagcor, meanwhile, is now spending less for coffee, according to Santiago.

The prices of the coffee that it now serves for free to casino customers range from P9.36 to P14.99 per cup. With a report from Marlon Ramos


Join us on


Complete stories on our Digital Edition newsstand for tablets, netbooks and mobile phones; 14-issue free trial. About to step out? Get breaking alerts on your mobile.phone. Text ON INQ BREAKING to 4467, for Globe, Smart and Sun subscribers in the Philippines.

More News:

Disclaimer: The comments uploaded on this site do not necessarily represent or reflect the views of management and owner of INQUIRER.net. We reserve the right to exclude comments that we deem to be inconsistent with our editorial standards.


Copyright 2014. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed. To subscribe to the Philippine Daily Inquirer newspaper in the Philippines, call +63 2 896-6000 for Metro Manila and Metro Cebu or email your subscription request here.
Factual errors? Contact the Philippine Daily Inquirer's day desk. Believe this article violates journalistic ethics? Contact the Inquirer's Reader's Advocate. Or write The Readers' Advocate:
c/o Philippine Daily Inquirer Chino Roces Avenue corner Yague and Mascardo Streets, Makati City, Metro Manila, Philippines Or fax nos. +63 2 8974793 to 94

Advertisement
Advertisement

Photos & Videos

  • President Benigno Aquino III. FILE PHOTO

    Aquino backs FOI bill, insists aide

    Read More

  • Presidential spokesman Edwin Lacierda: A board member of any GOCC can receive only up to P3 million annually, including bonuses and per diem. INQUIRER FILE PHOTO

    Palace: No war with bishops over reproductive health bill

    Read More

  • In his Sona, President Benigno Aquino praised the measures made by the DOH and the Department of Science and Technology to curtail dengue, singling out for special mention Health Secretary Enrique Ona and Science and Technology Secretary Mario Montejo. AP PHOTO

    Dengue cases in Philippines up by 16%

    Read More

  • poll

    INQUIRER.net poll: 40% of respondents think Aquino’s SONA excellent

    Read More

  • Lipa Archbishop Ramon Arguelles. Photo from southernluzoninquirer.com

    Aquino’s RH bill endorsement an open war on Church, bishops say

    Read More

  • Rep. Ben Evardone FILE PHOTO

    Despite Aquino snub, FOI will be pushed, lawmaker vows

    Read More

  • President Benigno Aquino III. FILE PHOTO

    Palace defends use of last year’s crime stats in SONA

    Read More

  • Abigail-Valte

    Aquino can’t stop Charter change moves—Palace

    Read More

  • President Benigno Aquino III. FILE PHOTO

    Aquino submits P2-trillion budget to Congress

    Read More

  • guyito

    Palace: No road map needed for ‘daang matuwid’

    Read More

  • Nonnatus Caesar Rojas FILE PHOTO

    Palace names Rojas permanent NBI chief

    Read More

  • Senate Majority Floor Leader Vicente Sotto III. INQUIRER FILE PHOTO

    Aquino statement on responsible parenthood ‘safe’ , says Sotto

    Read More

  • Hacienda Luisita workers. INQUIRER FILE PHOTO

    Luisita lands should be distributed in one year, says farmers group leader

    Read More

  • Senator Teofisto Guingona III. INQUIRER FILE PHOTO

    Guingona says Aquino’s SONA surpassed his expectations

    Read More

  • aquino-040512lr_IMG_6487

    Aquino: Philippines is no longer a joke

    Read More

  • ENRAGED protesters smash a police mobile along Commonwealth Avenue in Quezon City shortly before President Aquino delivered his Sona. MARIANNE BERMUDEZ

    6,000 cops block 5,000 protesters hurling stones

    Read More

  • guyito

    House ‘Great Wall’ shrine to historic impeachment

    Read More

  • President Benigno Aquino III. FILE PHOTO

    Aquino: Nothing is impossible

    Read More

  • INQUIRER FILE PHOTO

    Scores hurt as protesters clash with cops

    Read More

  • In his Sona, President Benigno Aquino praised the measures made by the DOH and the Department of Science and Technology to curtail dengue, singling out for special mention Health Secretary Enrique Ona and Science and Technology Secretary Mario Montejo. AP PHOTO

    Aquino defends new mining policy

    Read More

  • aquino-congress-sona

    Aquino: We’ve proven the impossible possible

    Read More

  • Bayan Muna Rep. Teodoro Casiño monitored the report of the fire fight and linked INQUIRER.net’s breaking story to his tweet. “This is one hell of a shootout,” he tweeted.  INQUIRER FILE PHOTO

    Aquino’s ‘good news’ not in sync with reality—Casiño

    Read More

  • Senate Majority Floor Leader Vicente Sotto III. INQUIRER FILE PHOTO

    No mention of RH bill in Sona, says Sotto

    Read More

  • Senator Franklin Drilon. INQUIRER FILE PHOTO

    Mining, sin tax bills should be passed, says Drilon

    Read More

  • In his Sona, President Benigno Aquino praised the measures made by the DOH and the Department of Science and Technology to curtail dengue, singling out for special mention Health Secretary Enrique Ona and Science and Technology Secretary Mario Montejo. AP PHOTO

    Aquino vows to step up infrastructure development

    Read More

  • Former Anak Mindanao party-list Representative Mujiv Hataman. Photo from congress.gov.ph

    Aquino calls ARMM governor ‘certified ghost buster’

    Read More

  • Protesters remove the barricade put up by riot police as they attempt to march closer to the Philippine Congress to protest the third State of the Nation Address of President Aquino on Monday, July 23, 2012, in Quezon city, northeast of Manila.  AP PHOTO/BULLIT MARQUEZ

    Police say Aquino Sona peaceful despite clash

    Read More

  • Protesters remove the barricade put up by riot police as they attempt to march closer to the Philippine Congress to protest the third State of the Nation Address of Philippine President Benigno Aquino III Monday, July 23, 2012 in Quezon city, northeast of Manila.  AP PHOTO/BULLIT MARQUEZ

    Clash with cops resulted from ‘frustration,’ say militants

    Read More

  • Vice President Jejomar Binay. INQUIRER FILE PHOTO / NIÑO JESUS ORBETA

    Binay gives Aquino Sona a ‘9’

    Read More

  • Manuel Villar  INQUIRER FILE PHOTO

    Villar rates Aquino’s Sona ‘good’

    Read More

  • Ombudsman Conchita Carpio Morales. INQUIRER FILE PHOTO

    Ombudsman Morales extolled in Aquino Sona

    Read More

  • aquino-040512lr_IMG_6487

    AFP to get more equipment, aircraft next year – Aquino

    Read More

  • President Benigno Aquino III. Malacañang Photo Bureau/File

    Aquino says reforms now the norm

    Read More

  • Former President Joseph Estrada.. INQUIRER FILE PHOTO

    Ex-President Estrada, senators assess Aquino gov’t

    Read More

  • Benigno-Aquino

    `Kayo po ang gumawa ng pagbabago. SONA ito ng sambayanang Pilipino’

    Read More

  • President Benigno Aquino III

    Aquino won’t ‘forgive and forget’ sins of past administration

    Read More

  • President Benigno Aquino III. Malacañang Photo Bureau/File

    Aquino sees 10M tourists coming to PH by 2016

    Read More

  • aquino-040512lr_IMG_6487

    Aquino lauds gov’t improved risk reduction capability

    Read More

  • President Benigno Aquino III. FILE PHOTO/MALACAÑANG PHOTO BUREAU

    Aquino says 3.1M jobs created in past 2 years

    Read More

  • President Benigno Aquino III. Malacañang Photo Bureau/File

    Aquino: Classroom shortage problem solved before 2014

    Read More

  • President Benigno Aquino III. FILE PHOTO/MALACAÑANG PHOTO BUREAU

    Aquino tells legislators: Pass Sin Tax bill

    Read More

  • President Benigno Aquino III. INQUIRER FILE PHOTO

    Aquino draws cheer for mentioning possible passage of RH bill

    Read More

  • INQUIRER FILE PHOTO

    Clash erupts again on Commonwealth Avenue, 2 media members injured

    Read More

  • aquino-congress-sona

    Philippines now open for business – Aquino

    Read More

  • President Benigno Aquino III

    Aquino: Reformed PhilHealth reaches more poor people

    Read More

  • aquino-040512lr_IMG_6487

    Aquino opens 3rd Sona with attack on past administration

    Read More

  • President Benigno Aquino III. Malacañang Photo Bureau/File

    Aquino arrives in House for Sona

    Read More

  • INQUIRER FILE PHOTO

    Protesters clash with cops in front of Ever Gotesco

    Read More

  • Senator Peter Allan Cayetano. PHOTO BY JESS YUSON

    Cayetano on charter change proponents: Proceed with caution

    Read More

  • Speaker Feliciano Belmonte. INQUIRER FILE PHOTO

    Lawmakers urged to pass K+12, RH bills

    Read More

  • INQUIRER FILE PHOTO

    Protesters remove steel barricade near Ever Gotesco in Quezon City

    Read More

  • Demonstrators torch 14-foot tall effigy of President Benigno Aquino III during their protest on Commonwealth Avenue, Quezon City Monday. Photo by Jamie Marie Elona of INQUIRER.net

    Protesters burn Aquino effigy

    Read More

  • 15th-congress-sona

    15th Congress sessions open for Aquino’s third Sona

    Read More

  • Senate President Juan Ponce-Enrile . JUNNY ROY/SENATE POOL

    Enrile wants to hear Aquino’s plan on job creation

    Read More

  • Jose de Venecia. INQUIRER file photo

    De Venecia, Bartolome, Carpio arrive at the House for Sona 2012

    Read More

  • Senate President Juan Ponce Enrile  INQUIRER FILE PHOTO

    Charter change among Senate’s priorities—Enrile

    Read More

  • Sona iffigy burning

    Protesters call Aquino’s 2-year rule pro-foreigners, ‘mostly talk than work’

    Read More

  • 21 senators present at early Monday session

    21 senators present at early Monday session; Pangilinan, Santiago absent

    Read More

  • Sona 2012 protest

    Militant farmers’ group clashes with police on Commonwealth Avenue

    Read More

  • MEDIA PROTEST

    Media members affiliated with government TV stations join Sona 2012 protesters

    Read More

  • 15th-congress-sona

    235 lawmakers present at House’s early Monday session for 2012 Sona

    Read More

  • Senate of the Philippines. INQUIRER FILE PHOTO

    Senate opens pre-Sona session

    Read More

  • President Benigno Aquino III. FILE PHOTO/MALACAÑANG PHOTO BUREAU

    What the nation wants to hear

    Read More

  • commonwealth-ave

    Police blockage on Commonwealth Avenue violates BP 880, says Bayan

    Read More

  • MTSAT ENHANCED-IR Satellite Image  11:32 p.m., 22 July 2012

    Rains expected on SONA day–Pagasa

    Read More

  • Protesters gather Monday, July 23, 2012, near the Ever Gotesco mall near the Batasan Pambansa along Commonwealth Avenue where President Benigno Aquino III will deliver his state of the nation address later in the day. NOY MORCOSO/INQUIRER.net

    Protesters mass near Congress ahead of Aquino’s speech

    Read More

  • INQUIRER FILE PHOTO

    Classes suspended in some Metro schools due to bad weather

    Read More

  • MTSAT ENHANCED-IR Satellite Image  11:32 p.m., 22 July 2012

    Protesters told: Bring umbrellas, raincoats

    Read More

  • WARM-UP PROTEST Militants parade effigies of President Aquino and Uncle Sam during a Sunday rally near Malacañang in preparation for a big one when the country’s highest official delivers his third State of the Nation Address Monday at the Batasang Pambansa Complex in Quezon City. RICHARD A. REYES

    PNP units on full alert for anti-Sona rallies

    Read More

  • guyito

    Sen. Arroyo to skip fashion parade of legislators

    Read More

  • WARM-UP PROTEST Militants parade effigies of President Aquino and Uncle Sam during a Sunday rally near Malacañang in preparation for a big one when the country’s highest official delivers his third State of the Nation Address Monday at the Batasang Pambansa Complex in Quezon City. RICHARD A. REYES

    Palace vows ‘truthful, inspiring’ 3rd SONA

    Read More

  • Senator Antonio Trillanes IV INQUIRER.net file photo

    Senator Trillanes says won’t attend Aquino SONA

    Read More

  • AQUINO REPORT CARD

    OK all the way, thumbs down on quite a few

    Read More

  • pagasa-logo

    Heavy rains forecast for Sona

    Read More

  • pnp-logo

    PNP assures Sona protesters cops will not carry guns

    Read More

  • Former Chief Justice Renato Corona. FILE PHOTO/SENATE POOL

    Corona expects more attacks from Aquino, says he’s moved on

    Read More

  • Presidential spokesman Edwin Lacierda: A board member of any GOCC can receive only up to P3 million annually, including bonuses and per diem. INQUIRER FILE PHOTO

    Palace hit for blaming courts on human rights slays

    Read More

  • Senate President Juan Ponce Enrile

    Congress pushes Charter change

    Read More

  • President Benigno Aquino III. FILE PHOTO/MALACAÑANG PHOTO BUREAU

    Lawmakers voice out what they expect to hear from Aquino’s 3rd Sona

    Read More

  • Speaker Feliciano Belmonte. INQUIRER FILE PHOTO

    Liberal Party not aggressively recruiting—Belmonte

    Read More

  • Former President and now Pampanga Representative Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo

    Arroyo seeks bishops’ prayers ‘to accept things she could no longer change’

    Read More

  • Former Philippine Amusement and Gaming Corp. chair Efraim Genuino. INQUIRER FILE PHOTO

    Genuino charged over P258-M coffee overprice

    Read More

  • Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo, NBN-ZTE Deal

    Arroyo wants to stop P366-M PCSO case

    Read More

  • President Benigno Aquino III . FILE PHOTO

    About time you quit blaming Arroyo, militants tell Aquino

    Read More

  • IMG-20120716-00475

    Militant group leaders snub pre-SONA dialogue with cops

    Read More

  • dinky-soliman

    CCT goal of easing poverty still way off

    Read More

  • Photo of the South Wing Building of the House of Representatives. Photo by INQUIRER.net's Karen Boncocan

    Some 5,000 cops to be deployed in Congress for Aquino speech

    Read More

  • itta-rosales

    Not one human rights violator convicted–CHR chief

    Read More

  • image-for-ARMM

    Gov’t reforms take roots at ‘cheating capital’ of PH

    Read More

  • Morales fires the gun signaling the start of a Run Against Corruption, at the Office of the Ombudsman where she was accompanied by more than 100 working citizens calling for the truth, during the Senate Probe on CJ Corona. INQUIRER FILE PHOTO

    Ombudsman is Aquino’s key weapon vs graft

    Read More

  • FILE PHOTO

    PSG inspects House ahead of President Aquino’s SONA

    Read More

  • FILE PHOTO/congress.gov.ph

    House preparations on high gear for Aquino State of the Nation Address

    Read More

  • MORALES: I have never met the President before. RAFFY LERMA

    It’s official: Morales new Ombudsman

    Read More

  • ANTIGOVERNMENT protesters burn an effigy of President Aquino along Commonwealth Avenue in Quezon City on Monday.  MARIANNE BERMUDEZ

    At A Glance

    Read More

  • President Aquino delivers his second State of the Nation Address at the Batasang Pambansa building in Quezon City on Monday, vowing to strengthen the government’s anticorruption drive to free up more resources and punish corrupt officials.  EDWIN BACASMAS

    ‘Thank you, my Bosses’

    Read More

  • President Benigno Aquino, lll.  AP file photo

    State of the Nation Address

    Read More

  • AQUINO IN FLAMES. Militants burn the effigy of President Benigno Aquino III during a protest along Commonwealth Avenue shortly before the Aquino delivers his speech I Congress Monday, July 25, 2011.

    Militants burn Aquino effigy

    Read More

  • Militant groups parade an effigy of President Benigno Aquino on Commonwealth Avenue ahead of the Chief Executive’s national address. MARIANNE BERMUDEZ/INQUIRER

    Militants gather at St. Peter’s Church

    Read More

  • SONA 2011, Protest, Farmers, Police - 1

    Farmers stopped from crossing police line

    Read More

  • ARROYOS IN THE HOUSE  Pampanga Representative Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo and her son Camarines Sur Representative Dato Arroyo were early birds at the morning session of the House of Representatives on Monday. RAFFY LERMA

    Arroyo arrives at House of Representatives

    Read More

  • SEEKING DIVINE GUIDANCE. Policemen and their officials hear mass early Monday before they are deployed to secure the areas leading to Congress at the Batasan Pambansa where President Benigno Aquino III will deliver his second State of the Nation Address.

    Some 5,000 cops, MMDA personnel deployed vs militants

    Read More

  • Traffic rerouting scheme on Commonwealth Avenue for Monday, when President Benigno Aquino delivers his second State of the Nation Address in Congress. Image courtesy of PNP

    Traffic build up on southbound lane of Commonwealth Ave. in QC

    Read More

  • THE USUAL EFFIGY  Members of Bagong Alyansang Makabayan prepare a giant effigy of President Aquino which the militant group will unveil in their Sona rally on Monday. RAFFY LERMA

    Militants prepare for ‘PeNoy’ effigy burning on Monday

    Read More

  • RUSH JOB A worker applies the finishing touches on the photo gallery of the House of Representatives where President Aquino will address the nation Monday. MARIANNE BERMUDEZ

    President to focus on transformation

    Read More

  • President Benigno Aquino III. AP FILE PHOTO

    Anti-corruption drive gains top Aquino SONA—Palace

    Read More

  • Traffic rerouting scheme on Commonwealth Avenue for Monday, when President Benigno Aquino delivers his second State of the Nation Address in Congress. Image courtesy of PNP

    Traffic re-routing scheme for Monday in QC’s Commonwealth area

    Read More

  • HERE’S LOOKING AT YOU. Former Commission on Elections (Comelec) official Lintang Bedol takes a glance to Comelec Chairman Sixto Brillantes as he answers questions during a press conference Tuesday, July 19, 2011 at the Comelec office. Bedol, who was allegedly linked to massive election fraud during the 2004 presidential election, surrendered to the authorities on Tuesday. AP

    Lintang Bedol arrives in Camp Crame

    Read More

  • PRICE OF FREEDOM  For the few dozen Filipinos living on remote Kalayaan Island, each day is a battle against loneliness and a love affair with nature. This photo handout released on July 13 shows Kalayaan, which means “Freedom” in Filipino, which was created in 1978 mainly to assert the Philippine claim to the disputed territory in the Spratlys. AFP / KALAYAAN MUNICIPAL OFFICE

    Hardy Filipinos fly flag, fight loneliness on Kalayaan isle

    Read More

  • A year into President Aquino’s term, foreign investors are still not keen on putting their money in the Philippines because of unstable laws and policies, among others.

    Aquino reports to the boss (Part 1)

    Read More

Copyright 1997-2011 INQUIRER.net | All Rights Reserved