‘Vigilance needed with FOI law’



MANILA, Philippines—The House of Representatives’ research body thinks a freedom of information (FOI) law would improve governance but also warns that getting government to sincerely implement it could be challenging and would require media and civil society vigilance.

As Congress prepares to debate the bill, the Congressional Policy and Budget Research Department (CPBRD) listed some suggestions on how to ensure the successful implementation of an FOI measure, which if passed into law would make government records open to the public.

In a policy brief, the CPBRD suggested manpower and procedural adjustments in every government agency to deal with public requests for records, among other things. The government would need to provide financial and logistical support for this but could also charge a reasonable fee to cover the cost of reproducing the documents, it said.

Policy exemption

Congress has also to debate which areas could be justifiably exempted from the disclosure policy, such as national security-related information.

However, the CPBRD cautioned that “the mere existence of an FOI law does not guarantee easy access to government records. Government’s sincerity is key to an honest-to-goodness disclosure policy,” it said, suggesting that civil society and media would need to keep up the pressure for the law’s implementation.

The CPBRD’s position in policy briefs does not necessarily reflect that of the representatives, or of the House as an institution.

Gov’t info access

The CPBRD brief said there was merit in the contention of civil society organizations that an FOI law was urgently needed to ensure that people could access government information—no matter who was in power.

But the CPBRD also said that even if the FOI bill became law, another challenge lay in ensuring its proper implementation, based on a survey by David Banisar of the Freedom of Information Project of Privacy International.

It noted that in Zimbabwe, for example, the access provisions were not implemented despite the existence of an FOI law. In Albania and Bosnia, many stakeholders were unaware of the disclosure policy, and the law was only intended for limited use.

In Panama, the government enacted an FOI law and then established a rule that deliberately contradicted the law. There had also been instances where information was withheld not to protect the state, but simply to spare national security groups from controversy.

The CPBRD said that to increase the chances of a successful implementation of an FOI law in the country, civil society organizations must be involved in the process.

“The chances of changing the policy from limited to full disclosure is high when there is pressure from civil society,” it said.

For example, media and civil society groups in Paraguay were able to get the government to amend provisions in the FOI law that were seen as restricting freedom of speech.

In the Philippines, some lawmakers are trying to tack on a “right of reply” clause provision that would impose restrictions on media rights to the FOI bill.


FOI, antitrust bills top House agenda

Palace boys chided for slow action on Freedom of Information bill

Freedom of info bill not President Aquino’s priority, NUJP laments

Recent Stories:

Complete stories on our Digital Edition newsstand for tablets, netbooks and mobile phones; 14-issue free trial. About to step out? Get breaking alerts on your mobile.phone. Text ON INQ BREAKING to 4467, for Globe, Smart and Sun subscribers in the Philippines.

Disclaimer: The comments uploaded on this site do not necessarily represent or reflect the views of management and owner of INQUIRER.net. We reserve the right to exclude comments that we deem to be inconsistent with our editorial standards.

Copyright © 2018,

To subscribe to the Philippine Daily Inquirer newspaper in the Philippines, call +63 2 896-6000 for Metro Manila and Metro Cebu or email your subscription request here.

Factual errors? Contact the Philippine Daily Inquirer's day desk. Believe this article violates journalistic ethics? Contact the Inquirer's Reader's Advocate. Or write The Readers' Advocate: c/o Philippine Daily Inquirer Chino Roces Avenue corner Yague and Mascardo Streets, Makati City, Metro Manila, Philippines Or fax nos. +63 2 8974793 to 94


  • SC candidate says Duterte can withdraw from ICC without Senate concurrence
  • Tears, confusion as Crimea mourns college shooting
  • Spider swarm cloaks Greek lake in 1,000-meter web
  • Pope indicates willingness to visit North Korea
  • DSWD, Philippine Army partner to build Lumad classrooms
  • Sports

  • Lyceum settles for no. 2, but adversity motivates Pirates
  • Rookie James Canlas proves worth in crucial win for San Beda
  • Huge Tokyo splash: PSL tankers triumph
  • Ildefonso ‘not thinking about’ UAAP rookie race, says Cansino deserves award
  • Belingon banking on support from Filipinos in Singapore in ONE unification bout
  • Lifestyle

  • Best pizza cities in the US for 2018 named by TripAdvisor
  • WATCH: Hurricane Michael survivors prepare food for neighbors outside damaged house
  • The fast and the furious: Mom chases down teen son who took her BMW
  • WATCH: Police rescue injured squirrel at shopping mall
  • Women make half of first-time guitar players — study
  • Entertainment

  • Rami Malek rocks as Freddie Mercury in ‘Bohemian Rhapsody’
  • How Andi has found the ‘best version’ of herself
  • ‘Tough job’ for Pietro’s future GF
  • Erotic thriller zeroes in on mental illness
  • DJ’s old-school charm, plus a bit of razzle-dazzle
  • Business

  • Low projected Dubai oil prices no reason to stick with excise taxes – Magdalo
  • BSP: Tech-based financial inclusion to boost GDP growth by 3%
  • BOI: Investment pledges rise to P454.8B from Jan-Sept
  • AVIA announces new members
  • Imports, harvest season halt soaring prices of rice
  • Technology

  • WATCH: Eggs recovered from critically injured turtles
  • Mark Zuckerberg’s daughter thinks he works at a bookstore; Facebook users retort
  • Postman, shopper, builder: In Japan, there’s a robot for that
  • Pornhub traffic skyrocketed during YouTube downtime
  • Facebook’s election ‘war room’ takes aim at fake information
  • Opinion

  • Politics is our maelstrom
  • Editorial cartoon, October 18, 2018
  • Awaiting health care for all
  • In search of ‘walang kamag-anak’
  • Saint Oscar Romero of El Salvador
  • Global Nation

  • No Filipino casualties in Crimea shooting
  • Loren wants climate change advocacy turned into local action
  • Robredo calls for diplomatic resistance vs China’s bold expansionism
  • PH signs oil exploration deal with Israeli firm
  • DA temporarily bans PH importation of birds from California

    • McDonald’s PH Chairman & Founder, George T. Yang turns over three performing arts studios for DLSU Manila

      Read More

    • Cops arrest 6 ‘Basag Kotse’ suspects

      Read More

    • Honest naia cabbie cited for exemplary deed

      Read More

    • Mom of 5-year-old girl with leukemia looking for more good samaritans

      Read More

    • Compensation commission releases P2.3-M to aid Marawi soldiers

      Read More

    • PNP can’t always fool public with ‘nanlaban’ claims – solons

      Read More

    • Poll: Most dislike NFL protests and Trump comments

      Read More

    • Former Mexico governor wanted in US arrested

      Read More

    • US: Nobel Peace choice doesn’t change US stance

      Read More

    • California becomes first ‘sanctuary state’ for undocumented migrants

      Read More

    • Mexican photojournalist found dead after kidnapping

      Read More

    • Moscow gets 130 fake bomb calls, evacuates 100,000 people

      Read More

    • Frustrated police appeal for public’s help in Vegas case

      Read More

    • US states declare emergency ahead of Tropical Storm Nate

      Read More

    • Trump’s one-two punch hits birth control, LGBT rights

      Read More