Environmental groups oppose proposed Manila Bay reclamation project


MANILA, Philippines—Civil society groups and environmentalists heaped criticisms on the proposed 148-hectare Manila Goldcoast Reclamation Project along Manila Bay during a hearing held on Monday.

Dr. Kelvin Rodolfo, Environmental Sciences Professor at the University of Illinois, said the reclamation project would pose lethal risks to many people including danger of land subsidence, storm surges, storm waves and further ecological damage to coastal ecosystem.

Environmental groups are also opposing the agreement of the National Government and the National Reclamation Authority (NRA) to reclaim 148-hectares along Manila Bay, saying further reclamation would not only damage the remaining coastal habitat and eco-system but will also effectively block the natural pathways of the river system flowing into the bay, thus increasing the threats of massive flooding in Metro Manila.

Eloiza Tolentino, coordinator of the Eco-Waste Coalition, said the reclamation project would need 19 million cubic tons of sand that would destroy coastal ecosystem.

Tolentino added that this poses bigger and more critical impact on the environment.

Economic growth vs. Livelihood

The NRA said that the National Reclamation Project (NRP) would generate huge potential investments to achieve economic growth and other investments.  In a statement, Manila Vice Mayor Isko Moreno said the NRP would spell the future of the country’s capital city.

“This project is for the city that is dying from poverty,” said Moreno.  According to him, this would generate 500, 000 jobs for Manileños and urged the public to support the project.

Dr. Ed Alabastro of Technotrix, proponent of the project, said the NRP would also generate P10 billion tax for the city of Manila.

Meanwhile, Save Manila Bay Coalition, which is composed of environmental and civil society groups, said the NRP would be at the expense of livelihoods of fisherfolk and the urban poor. Added to this, the group said the NRP would also be at the expense of existing business investments as well as the city’s culture, heritage, and tourism.

Cardinal Tagle in his statement stressed the values of stewardship and good governance. “We should find solutions which are for the common good of the people and not for the interest of few individuals,” he said.

The Manila Goldcoast Development Corporation (MGDC) is the main proponent of the NRP.  MGDC plans to reclaim 148 hectares between the Cultural Center of the Philippines and the US Embassy.  MGDC argued that the NRP would propel sustainable development in the city and in the country as well. The company also cleared the issue on storm surges and massive flooding in the metropolis,  saying wave reflectors will be installed to prevent storm surges.

Buhay Partylist representative and former Manila Mayor Lito Atienza , who is also present at the hearing,  presented pitfalls of the project.

Atienza said this would only further aggravate climate change, disasters, and flooding. This was seconded by his son Councilor Ali Atienza whose district will be greatly affected by the reclamation.

The public hearing on the proposed project was initiated by the Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR) but was later questioned by Rep.  Atienza because the members of the review committee were not even part of DENR and was deemed impartial.

Rodolfo, on the other hand, also questioned the credentials of the environmental experts of the proponents and the review committee saying, “It’s easy to say one is an expert, but they must show their credentials.”

Public citizens who attended the public hearing suggested that they be given a chance to talk and air their concerns on the said issue.

Recent Stories:

Complete stories on our Digital Edition newsstand for tablets, netbooks and mobile phones; 14-issue free trial. About to step out? Get breaking alerts on your mobile.phone. Text ON INQ BREAKING to 4467, for Globe, Smart and Sun subscribers in the Philippines.

Disclaimer: The comments uploaded on this site do not necessarily represent or reflect the views of management and owner of INQUIRER.net. We reserve the right to exclude comments that we deem to be inconsistent with our editorial standards.

Copyright © 2018,

To subscribe to the Philippine Daily Inquirer newspaper in the Philippines, call +63 2 896-6000 for Metro Manila and Metro Cebu or email your subscription request here.

Factual errors? Contact the Philippine Daily Inquirer's day desk. Believe this article violates journalistic ethics? Contact the Inquirer's Reader's Advocate. Or write The Readers' Advocate: c/o Philippine Daily Inquirer Chino Roces Avenue corner Yague and Mascardo Streets, Makati City, Metro Manila, Philippines Or fax nos. +63 2 8974793 to 94


  • DepEd starts probe on ‘starfish-throwing’ incident involving teachers
  • PNP to enforce stricter policy on police chiefs supervising erring cops
  • EU divorce deal in peril after two UK Cabinet ministers quit
  • Villanueva urges swift action on layoff of 400 Apo Cement workers
  • Turkey says Saudi explanation over Khashoggi murder ‘insufficient’
  • Sports

  • With La Salle struggling, Gonzales trying to figure out how to fit Samuel in
  • Alaska takes 2-1 lead over Meralco in PBA Governors’ Cup semis
  • Asian Cup to get video review starting in quarterfinals
  • South Korea’s ‘Garlic Girls’ accuse coaches of derailing team
  • Center of attention: Bucks’ Brook Lopez lights out from 3
  • Lifestyle

  • Study: Chinese to account for half of luxury sales by 2025
  • Leonard Cohen exhibit to tour internationally
  • US National Book Award goes to Sigrid Nunez for novel ‘The Friend’
  • WATCH: Black man fluent in Filipino sings ‘Mahal Na Mahal’, ‘Bakit Ba Ikaw?’
  • 5-year-old child dies of cancer in mother’s arms
  • Entertainment

  • Dingdong-Dennis starrer to be pitted vs Coco’s top-rated series
  • Brian McKnight to serenade PH fans in 2-city concert series
  • Agents of ambush, November 16, 2018
  • Tuldok, November 16, 2018
  • A. Lipin, November 16, 2018
  • Business

  • PAL voted ‘Most Improved Airline for 2019’, per global ratings site
  • NGCP pours P9.5-B to improve Metro Manila transmission system
  • BSP data shows weak dollar remittance growth in last two months
  • BAVI is first Filipino company to provide leadership coaching to store managers
  • Slower growth amid uncertainty gives IT-BPM industry second thoughts about future
  • Technology

  • Nepal’s first robot waiter is ready for orders
  • Facebook vied to conceal Russia meddling: NYT
  • ‘Command & Conquer’ remasters to be made by EA
  • PlayStation targets ‘PUBG’ date
  • Rare conservation win: Mountain gorilla population ticks up
  • Opinion

  • Tradition and transition
  • Editorial cartoon, November 15, 2018
  • Send it back to Seoul
  • Convenient senility
  • It’s not as bad as it looks
  • Global Nation

  • Pangilinan: Talks between Asean, China should be based on respect
  • Chinese weather stations in Spratlys ‘not claims of ownership’ – Locsin
  • US, PH conduct high-level dialogue to curb child trafficking
  • WATCH: ‘Many were involved’ in returning of Balangiga bells – Msgr. Quitorio
  • Take back your garbage ASAP, South Korea told

    • McDonald’s PH Chairman & Founder, George T. Yang turns over three performing arts studios for DLSU Manila

      Read More

    • Cops arrest 6 ‘Basag Kotse’ suspects

      Read More

    • Honest naia cabbie cited for exemplary deed

      Read More

    • Mom of 5-year-old girl with leukemia looking for more good samaritans

      Read More

    • Compensation commission releases P2.3-M to aid Marawi soldiers

      Read More

    • PNP can’t always fool public with ‘nanlaban’ claims – solons

      Read More

    • Poll: Most dislike NFL protests and Trump comments

      Read More

    • Former Mexico governor wanted in US arrested

      Read More

    • US: Nobel Peace choice doesn’t change US stance

      Read More

    • California becomes first ‘sanctuary state’ for undocumented migrants

      Read More

    • Mexican photojournalist found dead after kidnapping

      Read More

    • Moscow gets 130 fake bomb calls, evacuates 100,000 people

      Read More

    • Frustrated police appeal for public’s help in Vegas case

      Read More

    • US states declare emergency ahead of Tropical Storm Nate

      Read More

    • Trump’s one-two punch hits birth control, LGBT rights

      Read More