Environmental groups oppose proposed Manila Bay reclamation project


MANILA, Philippines—Civil society groups and environmentalists heaped criticisms on the proposed 148-hectare Manila Goldcoast Reclamation Project along Manila Bay during a hearing held on Monday.

Dr. Kelvin Rodolfo, Environmental Sciences Professor at the University of Illinois, said the reclamation project would pose lethal risks to many people including danger of land subsidence, storm surges, storm waves and further ecological damage to coastal ecosystem.

Environmental groups are also opposing the agreement of the National Government and the National Reclamation Authority (NRA) to reclaim 148-hectares along Manila Bay, saying further reclamation would not only damage the remaining coastal habitat and eco-system but will also effectively block the natural pathways of the river system flowing into the bay, thus increasing the threats of massive flooding in Metro Manila.

Eloiza Tolentino, coordinator of the Eco-Waste Coalition, said the reclamation project would need 19 million cubic tons of sand that would destroy coastal ecosystem.

Tolentino added that this poses bigger and more critical impact on the environment.

Economic growth vs. Livelihood

The NRA said that the National Reclamation Project (NRP) would generate huge potential investments to achieve economic growth and other investments.  In a statement, Manila Vice Mayor Isko Moreno said the NRP would spell the future of the country’s capital city.

“This project is for the city that is dying from poverty,” said Moreno.  According to him, this would generate 500, 000 jobs for Manileños and urged the public to support the project.

Dr. Ed Alabastro of Technotrix, proponent of the project, said the NRP would also generate P10 billion tax for the city of Manila.

Meanwhile, Save Manila Bay Coalition, which is composed of environmental and civil society groups, said the NRP would be at the expense of livelihoods of fisherfolk and the urban poor. Added to this, the group said the NRP would also be at the expense of existing business investments as well as the city’s culture, heritage, and tourism.

Cardinal Tagle in his statement stressed the values of stewardship and good governance. “We should find solutions which are for the common good of the people and not for the interest of few individuals,” he said.

The Manila Goldcoast Development Corporation (MGDC) is the main proponent of the NRP.  MGDC plans to reclaim 148 hectares between the Cultural Center of the Philippines and the US Embassy.  MGDC argued that the NRP would propel sustainable development in the city and in the country as well. The company also cleared the issue on storm surges and massive flooding in the metropolis,  saying wave reflectors will be installed to prevent storm surges.

Buhay Partylist representative and former Manila Mayor Lito Atienza , who is also present at the hearing,  presented pitfalls of the project.

Atienza said this would only further aggravate climate change, disasters, and flooding. This was seconded by his son Councilor Ali Atienza whose district will be greatly affected by the reclamation.

The public hearing on the proposed project was initiated by the Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR) but was later questioned by Rep.  Atienza because the members of the review committee were not even part of DENR and was deemed impartial.

Rodolfo, on the other hand, also questioned the credentials of the environmental experts of the proponents and the review committee saying, “It’s easy to say one is an expert, but they must show their credentials.”

Public citizens who attended the public hearing suggested that they be given a chance to talk and air their concerns on the said issue.

Recent Stories:

Complete stories on our Digital Edition newsstand for tablets, netbooks and mobile phones; 14-issue free trial. About to step out? Get breaking alerts on your mobile.phone. Text ON INQ BREAKING to 4467, for Globe, Smart and Sun subscribers in the Philippines.

Disclaimer: The comments uploaded on this site do not necessarily represent or reflect the views of management and owner of INQUIRER.net. We reserve the right to exclude comments that we deem to be inconsistent with our editorial standards.

Copyright © 2019,

To subscribe to the Philippine Daily Inquirer newspaper in the Philippines, call +63 2 896-6000 for Metro Manila and Metro Cebu or email your subscription request here.

Factual errors? Contact the Philippine Daily Inquirer's day desk. Believe this article violates journalistic ethics? Contact the Inquirer's Reader's Advocate. Or write The Readers' Advocate: c/o Philippine Daily Inquirer Chino Roces Avenue corner Yague and Mascardo Streets, Makati City, Metro Manila, Philippines Or fax nos. +63 2 8974793 to 94


  • Go advises Sanchez to stop dreaming about leaving ‘safer’ New Bilibid Prison
  • PDEA concerned over arrest of rappers involved in drugs
  • Sotto seeks review of law that sparked fear of Sanchez’s release
  • BREAK: Ex-DFA chief Yasay rushed to hospital hours after arrest
  • Locsin’s take on early release of Sanchez: ‘The law is wrong’
  • Sports

  • Cignal ends Petron’s reign to barge into PSL All-Filipino finals
  • Gilas women barge into Fiba 3×3 U18 quarters after splitting group stage games
  • For Celtics, USA World Cup camp is a preseason bonus
  • Para-rower dies after boat capsizes at world championships
  • Tokyo Paralympic lottery opens with 2.3M tickets available
  • Lifestyle

  • Downton cast reverse roles in Harper’s Bazaar shoot
  • Beauty notes: On Adèle Exarchopoulos’ messy updo
  • INTERNET GOLD: Watch Björk take apart her TV
  • Pewdiepie and Marzia’s wedding is the most wholesome thing ever
  • Fundador Supremo 18 wins world’s best brandy competition
  • Entertainment

  •  ‘Wala akong inahas’ – Julia Barretto
  • SZA teases new music coming ‘soon as f*ck’
  • WATCH: First full trailer of Apple original series ‘The Morning Show’
  • WATCH: Sylvester Stallone back to his roots in new trailer for ‘Rambo: Last Blood’
  • Aiko airs dismay over Bato’s ‘second chance’ remark on Sanchez
  • Business

  • ‘Hot money’ still leaving PH despite improved July inflow
  • Congress warned repeat of budget delay to stifle growth to below 5%
  • Bill for civilian gov’t workers’ pay hike to be sent to House in September  
  • Neda chief wary of risks of giving LGUs bigger funds
  • OceanaGold transforms mineral resources into human capital
  • Technology

  • Instagram users can now create own augmented reality filters via Spark AR Studio
  • Facebook rolls out ‘Clear History’ feature after months of delays
  • LOOK: Woman catches fish with two mouths
  • Russia to send ‘Fedor’ its first humanoid robot into space
  • French Guiana grapples with Asian craving for fish bladder
  • Opinion

  • Editorial cartoon, August 22, 2019
  • ‘Too security-conscious’
  • Tempest in a toilet
  • Think of the worker
  • Gina Lopez, environmental champion
  • Global Nation

  • Palace insists foreign ships need to get PH clearance for their security   
  • Carpio: Foreign warships passing PH waters don’t need clearance under UNCLOS
  • Despite UNCLOS, world’s ‘most disastrous dangers’ still pertain to maritime issues – Locsin
  • Filipino nursing assistant, BF arrested in US for taunting dementia patient
  • Locsin won’t publicize details of protest vs China: ‘I speak only to the Army’

    • Cordillera dishes show connection to the earth

      Read More

    • THIS WEEK’S FESTIVALS: May 19-25, 2019

      Read More

    • McDonald’s PH Chairman & Founder, George T. Yang turns over three performing arts studios for DLSU Manila

      Read More

    • Cops arrest 6 ‘Basag Kotse’ suspects

      Read More

    • Honest naia cabbie cited for exemplary deed

      Read More

    • Mom of 5-year-old girl with leukemia looking for more good samaritans

      Read More

    • Compensation commission releases P2.3-M to aid Marawi soldiers

      Read More

    • PNP can’t always fool public with ‘nanlaban’ claims – solons

      Read More

    • Poll: Most dislike NFL protests and Trump comments

      Read More

    • Former Mexico governor wanted in US arrested

      Read More

    • US: Nobel Peace choice doesn’t change US stance

      Read More

    • California becomes first ‘sanctuary state’ for undocumented migrants

      Read More

    • Mexican photojournalist found dead after kidnapping

      Read More

    • Moscow gets 130 fake bomb calls, evacuates 100,000 people

      Read More

    • Frustrated police appeal for public’s help in Vegas case

      Read More