CA junks Arroyo ‘midnight appointments’


The Court of Appeals. FILE PHOTO

MANILA, Philippines—The Court of Appeals has affirmed the constitutionality of President Benigno Aquino’s revocation of the so-called “midnight appointments” of his predecessor, Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo.

In a 23-page decision dated August 28, the Court of Appeals Former 8th Division dismissed the petitions for interventions filed by Irma Villanueva and Francisco Rosquita who asked for the nullification of Aquino’s Executive Order No. 2 that revoked appointments made by Arroyo during the 2010 election period.

“[T]he controversial EO 2 was a valid exercise of the executive powers of the President in ensuring that the rule on midnight appointments is properly implemented,” the appeals tribunal ruled in the decision written by Justice Noel Tijam.

The other division members, Justice Romeo Barza and Edwin Sorongon, concurred.

On March 3, 2010, Arroyo appointed Villanueva as administrator for the Visayas of the Board of Administrators of the Cooperative Development Authority under the Department of Finance. She took her oath of office on April 13, 2010.

Rosquita on the other hand, was appointed member of the National Commission on Indigenous Peoples on March 5, 2010. She took her oath on March 18, 2010.

Aquino issued EO 2 shortly after he assumed the presidency on June 30, 2010. Executive Secretary Paquito Ochoa later issued a memorandum revoking the appointments of Rosquita, Villanueva and others.

The NCIP executive director wrote a letter to the Civil Service Commission’s personnel policies and standards office on July 12, 2010, inquiring whether the employees of the government appointed before March 10, 2010 were considered midnight appointees.

The Commission replied in a letter dated August 31, 2010, stating that under CSC’s appointment rules, government employees appointed before March 10, 2010 were not considered midnight appointees, even if they took they oaths of office or assumed office after March 10, 2010.

Villanueva and Rosquita used the CSC declaration in contending that EO 2 revised the CSC’s appointment rules, and trampled on the CSC’s prerogative as an independent constitutional body.

However, the Court of Appeals stated that the rules formulated by the CSC “must not override, but must be in harmony with, the law it seeks to apply and implement.”

“We are of the considered view that petitioners-intervenors are midnight appointees within the contemplation of Section 15, Article VII of the 1987 Constitution,” the appeals justices said.

Section 15 prohibits an outgoing president from making appointments two months immediately before the next presidential elections and up to the end of his term.

The Aquino administration took the position that the appointments were invalid unless the appointee also took her or his oath of office or assumed office before the cutoff.

Recent Stories:

Complete stories on our Digital Edition newsstand for tablets, netbooks and mobile phones; 14-issue free trial. About to step out? Get breaking alerts on your mobile.phone. Text ON INQ BREAKING to 4467, for Globe, Smart and Sun subscribers in the Philippines.

Disclaimer: The comments uploaded on this site do not necessarily represent or reflect the views of management and owner of INQUIRER.net. We reserve the right to exclude comments that we deem to be inconsistent with our editorial standards.

Copyright © 2015,

To subscribe to the Philippine Daily Inquirer newspaper in the Philippines, call +63 2 896-6000 for Metro Manila and Metro Cebu or email your subscription request here.

Factual errors? Contact the Philippine Daily Inquirer's day desk. Believe this article violates journalistic ethics? Contact the Inquirer's Reader's Advocate. Or write The Readers' Advocate: c/o Philippine Daily Inquirer Chino Roces Avenue corner Yague and Mascardo Streets, Makati City, Metro Manila, Philippines Or fax nos. +63 2 8974793 to 94


  • Supporters ask during Roxas appearance: Where’s Leni?
  • Bautista to constituents: Give your votes to Roxas as ‘birthday gift’
  • Only Escudero, Robredo attend VP forum
  • Martin Diño tells Duterte: Turn PH as safe as Davao City
  • LOOKBACK: The last PH president at a climate conference
  • Sports

  • Kobe scores 13 after announcement, but Pacers beat Lakers
  • The NBA starts paying Kobe Bryant his farewell compliments
  • Spike for Peace: Soriano hopes to give a ‘better fight’ after loss to Thais
  • Kobe Bryant: A hero or a villain? Or both?
  • Grizzlies give Sixers their 18th straight loss
  • Lifestyle

  • Rick Astley’s Solaire Theatre concert tonight almost sold out
  • What are you reading?
  • CCP concert features 3 generations of Felipe de Leon music
  • Classical guitar reigns supreme
  • Cultural agencies, NGOs hold first national youth forum on heritage
  • Entertainment

  • 4th Impact eliminated from ‘The X Factor UK’
  • PH tops Europop singing contest
  • ‘Call Me Francesco': New film recalls pope’s darkest moments
  • Adele’s ’25’ sells record-breaking 3.38 million copies
  • Shamaine’s serenity in silk
  • Business

  • Change in Thanksgiving weekend spending stumps retailers
  • Black Friday online shopping rivals stores–US survey
  • PH nears deal with European free trade group
  • Biz Buzz: Deal or no deal
  • Burden of Eden
  • Technology

  • Gamers can help Duterte get bad guys with app
  • Virus that causes baby deformities found in dengue mosquitoes
  • Glad to be back in supersonic age, says Gazmin
  • Get ‘Rody to rumble’ with the ‘Go Duterte’ game
  • Blogger ‘Ebangelista’ writes Inquirer, warns Iglesia elders
  • Opinion

  • Helping MSMEs
  • Senators as judges
  • Trust Sotto over Carpio in SET ruling?
  • Magdalo boys address a historical distortion
  • It’s the car culture
  • Global Nation

  • Palace denies reports on ISIS abduction of OFWs in Syria
  • PH to join push for consensus in Paris summit
  • Envoy says calamities can erase PH gains
  • What world can learn from Filipinos
  • Air Force eyeing more sophisticated jets

    • Air pollution in Beijing hits hazardous levels

      Read More

    • Philippine Air Force welcomes 2 new fighter jets

      Read More

    • Stories of Paris attacks’ victims revisited

      Read More

    • 25 bodies found after landslide hits east China village

      Read More

    • ‘Hell:’ Famous Paris venue becomes scene of terror bloodbath

      Read More

    • Names, details of more victims emerge from Paris attacks

      Read More

    • France bombs Islamic State HQ, hunts attacker who got away

      Read More

    • Haze victims struggle to remain optimistic

      Read More

    • Haze crisis spreads with hot spots found in Papua

      Read More

    • MH17: Victims heard missile blast before their deaths

      Read More

    • Tales about kids for kids mark Children’s Month

      Read More

    • With VP bid, dictator’s son launches Palace comeback

      Read More

    • Pressroom Joker: ‘Scrooge of Congress’ rich in scoops

      Read More

    • Apec delegates enjoy Ilonggo hospitality

      Read More

    • Man denies trying to murder wife

      Read More